ÔÚÌÖÂÛ±¾Ô´æÓÐÖ®¶¨ÒåÇ°£¬Ó¦ÏÈÁ˽â·ðÍÓ¶Ô²»¾ß±¾ÔÒâÒåµÄ¡¸ÓС¹¡¸ÎÞ¡¹Ö®¶¨Òå¡£¡¶ÔÓ°¢º¬¾¡·¾í2µÚ37¾£º
¶ûʱ£¬ÊÀ×ð¸æÖî±ÈÇ𣺡¸ÎÒ²»ÓëÊÀ¼äÚº£¬ÊÀ¼äÓëÎÒÚº¡£ËùÒÔÕߺΣ¿±ÈÇð£¡ÈôÈç·¨ÓïÕߣ¬²»ÓëÊÀ¼äÚº¡£ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÓУ¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÓС£ÔƺÎΪ¡ºÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÓУ¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÓУ¿¡»±ÈÇð£¡É«ÎÞ³£¡¢¿à¡¢±äÒ×·¨£¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÓУ¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÓУ»ÈçÊÇ£¬ÊÜ¡¢Ïë¡¢ÐС¢Ê¶£¬ÎÞ³£¡¢¿à¡¢±äÒ×·¨£¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÓУ¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÓС£ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÎÞ£¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÎÞ£¬Î½É«Êdz£¡¢ºã¡¢²»±äÒס¢ÕýסÕߣ¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÎÞ£¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÎÞ£»ÊÜ¡¢Ïë¡¢ÐС¢Ê¶£¬³£¡¢ºã¡¢²»±äÒס¢ÕýסÕߣ¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÎÞ£¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÎÞ¡£ÊÇÃûÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÎÞ£¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÎÞ¡£±ÈÇð£¡ÓÐÊÀ¼ä¡¢ÊÀ¼ä·¨£¬ÎÒÒà×ÔÖª×Ô¾õ£¬ÎªÈË·Ö±ðÑÝ˵ÏÔʾ£»ÊÀ¼ääÎÞÄ¿Õß²»Öª²»¼û£¬·ÇÎÒ¾ÌÒ²¡£¡¹21
¾ÎÄÊ×ÏÈ˵Ã÷·ðÍÓ²»ºÍÊÀÈËÚº±ç£¬ÊÇÊÀÈËÓë·ðÍÓÚº±ç£¬ÒòΪ·ðÍÓ˵µÄÊÇ¡¸Èç·¨Ó¡£¡¸Èç·¨ÓµÄÏÖ´ú˵·¨ÊÇ¡¸ÊµÊÂÇóÊÇ£¬Ç¡ÈçÆä·ÖµÄ˵Ã÷Öî·¨µÄÊÂʵÕæÏࡹ£¬ÊÂʵÕæÏà¼ò³ÆΪ¡¸ÊµÏࡹ¡£µ¥´¿µÄÊö˵ÊÂʵµÄÕæÏ࣬µ±È»²»ÊÇÓëÈËÚº±ç£»ÒòΪ·²ÊÇÈÏʶÊÂʵÕæÏàÕߣ¬Ò²½«²»¿É±ÜÃâµÄ»á˵³öͬÑùµÄ»°¡£Òò´Ë¡¸ÊÂʵÕæÏࡹÊǼìÑéËù˵ÕæαµÄΨһ±ê×¼£¬ÊÇʵ֤µÄ»ù´¡¡£
½ÓÏÂÀ´ËµÃ÷·ðÍÓËæ˳ÊÀÈ˵ÄÑÔÓï±íÒ壬²»ÓëÊÀÈË·¢ÉúÔÚÑÔÓï±íÒåÉϳåÍ»µÄÁ¢³¡¡£·ðÍÓ˵¡¸ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÓУ¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÓС£¡¹¡¸ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÑÔÎÞ£¬ÎÒÒàÑÔÎÞ¡£¡¹ÎÒÃÇҪעÒâ·ðÍÓÔÚ˵¡¸ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹Ê±£¬Í¬Ê±Òâν×Å·ðÍÓ±¾ÉíÊÇ¡¸³öÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹µÄÒ⺡£²¢Í¹ÏÔ³ö·ðÍÓÓëÊÀÈ˵ļû½â»ù±¾ÉÏÊÇ¡¸³öÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹Ó롸ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹µÄ²îÒì¡£
·ðÍÓ˵£ºÎÞ³£±ä»¯µÄÎåÒõ³öÏÖ£¬ËûÖ»ÊÇËæ˳ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕ߶ø˵¡¸ÓС¹¡£ÊÂÎï³öÉúÁË£¬Î´À´Ò»¶¨»áÏûÃð£¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕ߶¼³ÆÕâÖÖÊÂÎïµÄ³öÉúÓë´æÔÚΪ¡¸ÓС¹¡£·ðÍÓÖ¸³ö¡¸ÓС¹µÄ³ÆºôÊǾßì¶ÜÐԵģ¬µ«·ðÍÓËæ˳ÕâÑùµÄ³ÆºôÀ´½Ìµ¼ÊÀÈË¡£Òò´Ë±í´ï³ö·ðÍÓ¶Ô¡¸ÓС¹µÄ¶¨Ò壺ÒÔÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËùÄÜÖ¸³Æ³öÀ´µÄËùÓз¶³ëÀ´¶¨Ò塸ÓС¹¡£
·ðÍÓÓÖ˵£ºÎåÒõÏûÃðÖÐÓÐËüµÄ³£×¡ÐÔ£¬ËûÖ»ÊÇËæ˳ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕ߶ø˵¡¸ÎÞ¡¹¡£ÊÂÎïÏûÃðÓÖÄܹ»ÔÙ³öÉú£¬Ò»¶¨ÓÐÄܹ»³öÉúÊÂÎïµÄÁíÒ»¸ö³£×¡ÐÔ£¬ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕ߶¼³ÆÕâÖÖÊÂÎïµÄÏûÃðΪ¡¸ÎÞ¡¹¡£·ðÍÓÖ¸³ö¡¸ÎÞ¡¹µÄ³ÆºôÊǾßì¶ÜÐԵģ¬µ«·ðÍÓËæ˳ÕâÑùµÄ³Æºô¡£Òò´Ë±í´ï³ö·ðÍÓ¶Ô¡¸ÎÞ¡¹µÄ¶¨ÒåÊÇ£ºÒÔÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËùÄÜÖ¸³Æ³öµÄËùÓз¶³ëÀ´¶¨Ò塸ÎÞ¡¹£¬²»½«ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËù²»ÄÜÖ¸³Æ³öÀ´µÄÄܳöÉúÊÂÎïµÄÁíÒ»³£×¡ÐÔ³ÆΪ¡¸ÎÞ¡¹¡£
·ðÍÓÈÏΪһÇÐÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß½«ÊÂÎïµÄ³öÉú¼°ÏûÃð³ÆºôΪ¡¸ÓС¹¡¸ÎÞ¡¹£¬ÊǾßÓÐì¶ÜÐÔµÄÓÃÓµ«ÎªÁ˲»ÓëÖ®·¢ÉúÑÔÓï±íÒåÉϵijåÍ»£¬Ëæ˳ÕâÑùµÄÓÃÓ¶ø·´¹ýÀ´ÒÔÖ®¶¨Ò塸ÓС¹¡¸ÎÞ¡¹ËùÖ¸³ÆµÄ·¶Î§¡£¡¸ÓС¹Ó롸ÎÞ¡¹ÊÇÒÔÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËùÄÜÖ¸³ÆµÄ·¶³ëΪ·¶Î§¡£
¡¸ÓС¹ÔÚ·ð½ÌÖпÉÒÔÓ롸ÊÀ¼ä¡¹ÊÓΪͬµÈµÄÒâÒåµÄ¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÊÀ¼ä¿ÉÒÔÂÔ·ÖΪ¡¸ÈýÓС¹¼´¡¸Óû½çÓС¹¡¸É«½çÓС¹¡¸ÎÞÉ«½çÓС¹¡£»òϸ·ÖΪ¡¸¶þÊ®ÎåÓС¹£¬½«ÊÀ¼ä×ö²»Í¬µÄ·ÖÀ࣬¼ÓÒÔ½â˵²»Í¬µÄ¡¸ÓС¹µÄ²î±ð¼°ÐγÉÔÒò¡£
¡¸ÎÞ¡¹ÓÖÊÇʲôÒâÒåÄØ£¿»ù±¾ÉÏÓÐÈýÖÖÒâÒ壺
1¡¢ÈýÓС¢¶þÊ®ÎåÓÐδ³öÉúÇ°£¬¡¸ÎÞ¡¹ÈýÓС¢¶þÊ®ÎåÓУ»
2¡¢ÈýÓС¢¶þÊ®ÎåÓÐÏûÃðÁË£¬¡¸ÎÞ¡¹ÈýÓС¢¶þÊ®ÎåÓУ»
3¡¢¹ýÈ¥²»Ôø³öÉú¹ý£¬ÏÖÔÚûÓеģ¬Î´À´Ò²²»»á³öÉúµÄÊÂÎï³ÆΪ¡¸ÎÞ¡¹£¬Èç·ðÍÓ³£ÒÔ¡¸¹êëÍýǡ¹ËµÃ÷¡£
ÄÇôµÚ1¡¢2ÖÖÄܹ»ËµÊÇ¡¸ÎÞ¡¹Âð£¿ÕâÁ½ÖÖÒâÒåÓëµÚ3ÖÖµÄÒâÒåÏàͬÂð£¿ÕâЩÈýÓС¢¶þÊ®ÎåÓеÄËùÓÐÊÂÎÖÕ¾¿ÊÇÒªÏûÃðµÄ£¬ÏûÃðÁË£¬»¹¿ÉÒÔ³ÆΪ¡¸ÓС¹Â𣿳öÉúÇ°£¬¿ÉÒÔ³ÆΪ¡¸ÓС¹Âð£¿Õâ¾ÍÊÇ·ðÍÓËù˵µÄÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßÖ¸³ÆµÄ¡¸ÓС¹¡¸ÎÞ¡¹µÄì¶ÜÐÔ¡£ÕâÑùµÄì¶ÜÐÔ£¬ÏÖ´úµÄѧÕßÒàÓÐÂÛ¼°¡£Æ©È磺ÏÖ´úѧÕßÍþÁ®Ë¹£¨C. J. F. Williams£©ÈÏΪ¡¸ËÕ¸ñÀµ×´æÔÚ¡¹£¬Õâ¸öÃüÌâÊÂʵÉÏÒѾÄÚº¬ÓÚ¡¸ËÕ¸ñÀµ×²»ÔÙ´æÔÚ¡¹ÒÔ¼°¡¸ËÕ¸ñÀµ×¿ÉÄÜ´Óδ´æÔÚ¹ý¡¹ÕâÁ½¸öÒâÒå¶ø¼ÓÒÔÂÛÊö22¡£
ÕâÀï·ðÍÓ¶¨ÒåµÄ¡¸ÓС¢ÎÞ¡¹ÊÇÓëÏÖ´úÕÜѧ¶¨Ò塸´æÓС¹£¨existence, being£©ÊÇÏàͨµÄ£¬²»ÂÛÆäÂÛÊöÊÇ·ñ¾ß±¾ÔÒâÒå¡£ÒòΪÓÐÎÞÊÇ´ÓÉúÃðµÄÏÖÏó¼ÓÒÔ¶¨Òå¼°ÂÛÊöµÄ£¬ÊǴӹŵ½½ñµÄÊÀ¼äÖÇÕߣ¨°üº¬¶«Î÷·½ÕÜѧ¼°×ڽ̼ң©ËùÄÜÂÛÊöµÄ·¶³ë¡£ÕâÆäÖÐÒþº¬ÁíÒ»¸öÒâÒ壬¾ÍÊÇ£º¼´Ê¹´Ó¹Åµ½½ñÒ»ÇÐÊÀ¼äÖÇÕߣ¬¶Ô¾ßÓб¾ÔÒâÒåµÄ´æÓÐÌá³öµÄÈκμÙ˵¡¢ÀíÂÛ»òÍÆÂÛ£¬È«²¿ÊÇ°üÀ¨ÔÚ¡¸ÓÐÎÞ¡¹µÄ·¶³ëÖС£ÒòΪÕâЩÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËùÄܹ۲쵽µÄ·¶³ë£¬Ö»ÏÞÓÚ¾ßì¶ÜÐԳƺôµÄÉúÃ𷨣»ËûÃÇËùÌá³öµÄ¼Ù˵¡¢ÀíÂÛ¼°ÍÆÂÛ£¬ÒàÊÇÊôÓÚ¾ßÉúÃðÐԵġ¸ÓÐÎÞ¡¹·¶³ë¡£¼Ù˵¡¢ÀíÂÛ¼°ÍÆÂÛδ³öÏÖÇ°ÊÇ¡¸ÎÞ¡¹£¬³öÏÖºóÊÇ¡¸ÓС¹£¬Î´À´ÈËÀà¾Óס»·¾³»ÙÃðºó£¬Ò»Çнԡ¸ÎÞ¡¹¡£
ÓÐÎÞËù¶¨ÒåµÄ·¶³ëÒ²ÊÇÔµÆ𷨵ķ¶³ë£¬ÒòΪԵÆ𷨶¨ÒåÒ»Çз¨¡¸´ËÓйʱËÓУ¬´ËÃð¹Ê±ËÃ𡹣¬½ÔÊÇÓÐÉúÓÐÃðÖ®·¨¡£ÔµÆð·¨ÊÇÊÀ¼äÖÇÕßËù˵µÄ´æÓС¢ÓÐÓëÎÞ¡£23 ÄÇô¾ß¡¸³öÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹µÄ·ðÍÓÓ롸ÊÀ¼äÖÇÕß¡¹µÄ²î±ðÊÇʲô£¿·ðÍÓ¶¨Òå¾ßÓб¾ÔÒâÒåµÄ¡¸´æÓС¹ÄÚºÓÖÊÇʲôÄØ£¿
21 ¡¶´óÕý²Ø¡·²á2£¬Ò³8¡£
22 C. J. F. Williams, Being, Identity, and Truth, Oxford, O.U.P., 1992, pp.28-30.¸ÃÎÄÖоÙÀý“Lord Hailsham no longer exists.”ÊÇ˵£º“It used to be the case that (Lord Hailsham exists), but it is not now the case that (Lord Hailsham exists).” “Amy Williams might never have existed.”ÊÇ˵£º“It might have been the case that it was always the case that (Amy Williams exists).”³ý·Ç¡¸A´æÔÚ¡¹ÓÐÒâÒ壬·ñÔò¡¸A²»´æÔÚ¡¹±ãÎÞÓÐÒâÒå¡£
23 ´ÓÊÀ¼äÖÇÕߵĽǶÈÀ´¿´£¬ËûÊÇ×ÔÈÏΪÒѾ´¥¼°±¾ÔµÄ̽ÌÖ£»µ«ÒÀ·ðÍӵĶ¨Ò壬ÄÇÖ»ÊÇÏëÏ󡢲²⣬¹ÊÈÔ¹éÊôÓÚÓÐÎ޵ķ¶³ë¡£